Just J.Faye

Hiking & Other Adventures

  • Home
  • About
  • Index
  • Hikes
  • Travel
  • Recipe
  • Workout
  • Other things

Peanut Butter Stuffed Jalapeños

November 15, 2014 by Jenna

I’m going to spice things up a bit. It’s Saturday, why not get a little crazy? And what’s crazier than jalapeños?

NOTE: Lots of things are crazier than jalapeños. However, this does not stop me from telling you about these amazing peanut butter stuffed jalapeños. peanut butter stuff jalapeños I went to Butcher and the Boar for dinner a couple of weeks ago. This place is soooo good. If you live near Minneapolis, please go. Make reservations right now. They have an awesome floor made of pennies, a huge selection of good meats and sausages, and a lot of bourbon. Check.It.Out.

Besides bourbon and meat and pennies, they also have these amazing stuffed jalapeños. Initially one would think they are stuffed with cream cheese, which is, you know, cool and all. But noooo. No, these are stuffed with a peanut butter cream cheese mixture. PEANUT BUTTER. Then they are baked and sprinkled with feta and golden raisins.

Delicious. They are unlike anything I have ever tried before.

Peanut butter in jalapeños – weird, right? It works. Those people at Butcher and the Boar know what they are doing.

Anyways, I had to recreate them.

I wish I could say that my version was as delicious as the real thing, but I cannot. I am not a master chef and posses very little skill in the kitchen. I just like to experiment, cook, and eat. However, I will say that these are still pretty delicious.

Not only are they delicious, they are also easy to make. peanut butter stuff jalapeños We take our jalapeños, cut them in half, and then scrape out the seeds. Next we make the filling by mixing together cream cheese and peanut butter with a little bit of lime juice. The filling is stuffed into the jalapeño halves and placed in the oven for 25 minutes.

peanut butter stuff jalapeños Now it’s time to place them on a serving tray, sprinkle them with feta cheese and golden raisins, and then add a drizzle of honey.

peanut butter stuff jalapeños If you think about it, these are kind of like a fancier, less healthy, spicier version of ants on a log. The jalapeño replaces the celery (both green). The peanut butter is still there, but cream cheese is added to it. Raisins are placed on top, but are golden and, therefore, more sophisticated.

Do you see it or am I crazy?

Again, it’s Saturday.

peanut butter stuff jalapeños I think these stuffed jalapeños would be a great little appetizer to serve at a gathering of friends, like Friendsgiving for example. You can prep the jalapeños ahead of time and place them in the oven right before your guests arrive.

You can also wrap them in bacon, because I think that would be awesome and no one would yell at you for doing this. Unless all your friends are vegetarian. Then that’s just completely rude on your part. But then you can eat all the bacon peanut butter jalapeños yourself. So, do what you want.

You can also make them and eat them for dinner with cauliflower mashed potatoes.

But who does that?

No one.

Ok, me. I did last night.

Peanut Butter Stuffed Jalapeños
 
Print
Prep time
5 mins
Cook time
25 mins
Total time
30 mins
 
These are not your typical stuffed jalapeños. The classic cream cheese filling is elevated with the addition of peanut butter and lime juice. They are then baked and topped with feta cheese, golden raisins, and honey. A quick and easy appetizer to pull together for guests!
Serves: 12 servings
Ingredients
  • 4oz cream cheese, softened
  • ½ cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1 tablespoon lime juice
  • 6 jalapeños, halved lengthwise, seeded
  • Garnishes: feta cheese, golden raisins, honey
Instructions
  1. Heat oven to 375 degrees. Line cookie sheet with foil.
  2. In small bowl, mix cream cheese, peanut butter, and lime juice.
  3. Place the jalapeño halves on the cookie sheet and fill with the peanut butter mixture.
  4. Bake 25 minutes.
  5. Place jalapeños on a serving platter, sprinkle with feta cheese and golden raisins, and drizzle with honey. These are best served warm.
3.2.2802

peanut butter stuff jalapeños

Share this:

Filed Under: Recipe Tagged With: appetizer, easy, recipe

« Thursday Things 11.13.14
Superset Tabata Workout »

Comments

  1. i8bugs says

    August 7, 2016 at 7:46 pm

    Mine are about to come off the grill…don’t have honey but do have real maple. Will use an eye dropper to put it on so I don’t overpower it.

    • jenna @ justjfaye.com says

      August 7, 2016 at 9:28 pm

      Real maple sounds like a delicious alternative! I hope you love them!

hello and welcome!

my name is jenna, but you can call me j.faye. i am a lover of food, mountains, and sunshine. read more…

Follow Me

  • Bloglovin
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Never Miss A Post

receive updates via email:

Instagram

jenna.faye.ivey

Thankful for this crew ❤️ Thankful for this crew ❤️
Winter mode: activated. #snow #winter #mountains Winter mode: activated. 

#snow #winter #mountains #mountainlife #getoutside #outdoors #coloradohikingmoms #keepthelittleswild #liveferal #boymom #colorado #outdoorkids
Hike-or-treat & trunk-or-treats! It was a fun Hall Hike-or-treat & trunk-or-treats! It was a fun Halloween week with our little Mickey 🎃
The leaves. The views. The company! What an incred The leaves. The views. The company! What an incredible experience for our first two-nighter and last camping trip of the year (probably).

Thanks to @adventuresinnoticing & @anni_martini for being amazing friends/aunties. 

#colorado #camping #fall #leafpeeping #mountains #keepthelittleswild #coloradohikingmoms #feraldenver #outdoorsymom #boymom #dogmom #getoutside #lifeoutdoors #lifeofadventure
Cozy season is officially here ✨ #fall #cozy #c Cozy season is officially here ✨

#fall #cozy #camping #keepthelittleswild #coloradohikingmoms #getoutside #lifeofadventure #motherhood #family #boymom #dogmom #outdoorsymom #rimby #coloradomom
My open heart surgery was 7 years ago and it’s a My open heart surgery was 7 years ago and it’s an anniversary I will never not celebrate. 

I carried a lot of trauma with me for a long time. I was nervous for every hike, every workout, religiously checking my heart rate, wondering if this would be the time my heart fails me again. Very dramatic, I know. But I kept at it, doing these things I love to do, working through the fear. Now the intrusive thoughts are few and far between. 

So here I am 7 years later, a stronger person both physically and mentally, hanging out at the top of a mountain with my babies after a nice, challenging hike.  It’s all I really want. 

I’m so grateful for this life and for the people who continue to support me ❤️

#openheartsurgery #heartwarrior #myocardialbridge #heartattacksurvivor #recoveryjourney #celebrate #adventure #lifeoutdoors

Copyright © 2025 · Foodie Child Theme by Shay Bocks · Built on the Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress